Published by
Stanford Medicine

Behavioral Science, Health Policy, Pediatrics, Research

Study finds many teachers, doctors mistaking immaturity for ADHD

kgarten.jpg

What drives the diagnosis of ADHD in kids? More than just severity of symptoms, certainly: income, race, educational attainment of parents and state residency all appear to play some part. So, somewhat disturbingly, does the disposition of teachers – who might have misidentified nearly 1 million kids as attention-deficit simply because they’re younger (and less mature) than their classmates, according to a study released today:

“If a child is behaving poorly, if he’s inattentive, if he can’t sit still, it may simply be because he’s 5 and the other kids are 6,” said [Todd] Elder, assistant professor of economics [at Michigan State University]. “There’s a big difference between a 5-year-old and a 6-year-old, and teachers and medical practitioners need to take that into account when evaluating whether children have ADHD.”

Researchers looked at a longitudinal study of 12,000 students, comparing ADHD diagnosis and medication rates between the youngest and oldest children in a grade. They found the youngest were 60 percent more likely to be diagnosed with ADHD than the oldest while they were in kindergarten; and by the time they reached fifth and eighth grades, they were twice as likely to be prescribed stimulants. The researchers conclude 20 percent of the 4.5 million U.S. children labeled ADHD have been misdiagnosed.

Needless to say, the implications of misdiagnosis are huge at the societal and personal level: Elder says as much as $500 million a year is wasted on unnecessary medication; and the health effects of long-term stimulant use by children are unclear.

The study will appear in the upcoming edition of the Journal of Health Economics.

Photo by Woodleywonderworks

3 Responses to “ Study finds many teachers, doctors mistaking immaturity for ADHD ”

  1. Tim Says:

    Up to a million kids may have been misdiagnosed due to being the youngest in their class. How many millions more have been misdiagnosed due to poor diets, no exercise, and medical professionals who are trained to grab their prescription pad anytime a child walks through their door?

  2. Gina Pera Says:

    Did you actually read the study?
    Has it been replicated by others?
    Did you question why this study was conducted by an economics professor?
    Did you seek comment from a respected ADHD expert?
    If not, why are you posting this, which is essentially a press release, on this blog?
    I don’t get it.

  3. Julia James Says:

    Hi Gina,
    Thanks for your comment. We often, but not always, seek input from Stanford or outside experts on the studies we write about. In this case, we welcome you and other readers to share your thoughts on the research.

Comment


Please read our comments policy before posting

Stanford Medicine Resources: