Skip to content

Why doctors prescribe opioids to patients they know are abusing them

As an addiction psychiatrist, I was recently asked to consult on whether a patient hospitalized for severe low back pain suffered from opioid addiction. The odd thing about the consult was that it was obvious to even the casual observer that the patient was addicted to opioids: Her personal narrative was marked by the classic downward spiral of a drug-ravaged life, including loss of jobs, friends, family, and a recent near-death narcotic overdose; a "CURES" search, which allows authorized health care providers practicing in California to track prescriptions for controlled substances, revealed that in the past 4-5 weeks alone she had obtained prescriptions for more than 1,200 opioid pills; and two psychiatrists on two prior hospital admissions had already documented "opioid dependence", the formal "Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders" term for opioid addiction.

So why the repeat-consult to tell the primary team what they already knew? Because the patient's treating physicians, albeit fully aware that opioids were destroying her life, were uncomfortable denying her opioids for pain and wanted validation that withholding opioids was an acceptable course of action.

As I describe in a New England Journal of Medicine Perspective piece (subscription required), physicians today experience intense professional pressure to prioritize pain treatment above other competing clinical issues. And the reasons are as much cultural and financial as related to the healing arts:

  • Patients now evaluate their doctors on customer satisfaction surveys which can influence professional advancement and national reputation, and doctors who deny patients’ requests for pain pills are likely not to get very good survey ratings.
  • Today’s cultural ethos of ‘all suffering should be avoided’ encourages patients to believe that any level of subjective pain is unacceptable, and that doctors have a responsibility to remove the pain, lest the patient, in addition to being in pain, is psychologically traumatized by having to experience pain.
  • Writing a prescription for opioids is fast, easy, and readily reimbursed by third-party payers, whereas targeting addiction requires time, is complex, and is seldom financially rewarded.

My article goes on the make some recommendations about how these problems might be addressed. But until there's a cultural paradigm shift in which addiction is acknowledged by patients, doctors, and third-party payers as a disease that inflicts its own kind of suffering and demands its own treatment, the current national epidemic of prescription opioid abuse will continue.

Anna Lembke, MD, is an assistant professor of psychiatry and behavioral sciences at Stanford.

Popular posts

Category:
Genetics
Sex biology redefined: Genes don’t indicate binary sexes

The scenario many of us learned in school is that two X chromosomes make someone female, and an X and a Y chromosome make someone male. These are simplistic ways of thinking about what is scientifically very complex.